Self-assessment involves the metacognitive ability to use ones’ own internal processes to evaluate aspects of one’s own learning, such as:
– the quality of one’s learning processes;
– the quality of the work outputs one produces;
– the effective use of predictive cues for competence and ability;
– the flexible use of strategies to support understanding;
– measuring the impact of one’s attainment of skills and understanding.
(Di Francesca et al., 2016; Panadero & Alonso-Tapia, 2013; Panadero, 2017; Schneider & Preckel, 2017).
The quality of assessment design impacts student self-management of assessment and feedback processes. This insert from the EAT-Erasmus Self-Regulation Report summarises some of the key challenges in developing and supporting self-assessment.
click image to enlarge
As Evans (2022) notes, self-assessment abilities can be developed through use and training, there is evidence to suggest that not all students benefit from this development to the same extent (Guest & Riegler, 2017). Some students will gain more benefits from self-assessment than others, depending on their motivation, confidence, and the alignment of their own goals with those of their educators (Farrell et al., 2017).
Effective self-assessment and self-evaluation requires scaffolding of the process (at least in the initial stages; once a learner is experienced in these skills they can become self-reliant in them). Supporting learners in the effective use of the resources and opportunities within the assessment environment is vital.
Scaffolding needs to overcome barriers (see this figure) and support students to think in different ways (Bjork, 2017; Kapur, 2008).
click image to enlarge
Supporting effective self-evaluation (the ability of students to be able to accurately monitor their work and to have an awareness of their overall self-assessment capability) is complex. There are many factors that can bias one’s own self-evaluation judgement, including:
– information available to the learner
– inaccurate memories of events and their own actions (Eva & Regeher, 2011)
– self-beliefs about their own overall self-assessment ability (whether accurate or not)
– impact performance (experience of performance or failure)

Global judgements of one’s abilities (accurately aggregating perceptions over multiple experiences) require multiple opportunities of self-assessment and self-evaluation to develop effectively. So continual and repeated use of these activities is important.
The use, and development, of self-evaluation skills needs to be encouraged from the outset of each assessment task.
As this figure shows, self-evaluation needs to be undertaken by the learner before, during, and after the assessment.
click image to enlarge
In particular, support before the start of the assessment (inducting students into the language and meaning of assessment) supports students’ ability to monitor their own learning (Eva & Regeher, 2011). Refining, and re-setting beliefs is important during the assessment, and then reflecting on performance (including feedback from the assessor) is important afterwards.
Learners need support in being able to use internal cues (self-perceptions and comparisons to criteria/standards), and external cues (guidance and feedback from peers and educators) to predict their own performance more accurately.
This ability to self-evaluate is facilitated by:
– provision of explicit assessment task guidance before beginning;
– engagement with marking criteria from the outset;
– explicit modelling of self-assessment strategies as part of the learning process. (Dinsmore, 2017; Panadero & Alonso-Tapia, 2013).

REFLECTION ACTIVITY
Students’ vary in their self-regulation abilities – how do we best support students’ with different learning needs to develop such skills?
What would you say are the main challenges to students effectively assessing their own performance?
What are the reasons why students might have varied abilities in this regard?
Once you have identified your perceptions of these issues, based on your own experience, watch this short video, which will address some of these issues, think about how they relate to your own experiences and your context as an educator.
It is clear, therefore, that self-assessment and self-evaluation are not innate skills. They need to be supported and developed by scaffolded activities.
The following sections will focus on ways in which we can design curricula and assessments themselves to embed self-assessment and self-evaluation of outputs for students.


