A key consideration for any feedback is that students need to have the opportunity to apply what they have learned in any final assessment of their learning.
Just as constructive alignment requires us to think about how the assessment relates to the learning outcomes and teaching approaches, so we need to think about how the formative feedback aligns with the summative work the students will undertake.
Without a direct link and potential positive impact on the summative assessment task, the formative task, and its feedback, are relatively pointless.
Miller et al. (2010; cited in Evans, 2013) highlighted four key elements of effective feedback. Two of these are of significant importance here, namely:
(a) feedback should be theoretically grounded: “designers must focus on creating opportunities for evolving support, feedback, and assessment, not simply the delivery of content”;
(b) feedback should be aligned with goals and the nature of the task: “designers should align feedback with goal setting through clear descriptions of student goals and expectations”;
These two factors, the requirement to develop theoretical underpinnings for the content, and the clear alignment with the goals of the assessment task, highlight the importance of the direct and explicit link between the formative activities and the summative assessment.
This diagram summarises some of the intended outcomes of a summative assessment (in blue) and the requirements of a formative opportunity (in yellow) that would align with that assessment approach.
click image to enlarge
The ideal approach when designing formative activities, or formative assessments with feedback, is to identify the key skills being tested in the summative assessment, and to identify the most impactful feedback that could be offered for those skills.
What would be the most effective format for that guidance, in order to best support the development of that skill or understanding. Then work backwards from there to define what the summative and formative assessment tasks could be (see this figure).
click image to enlarge
REFLECTION ACTIVITY
Identify an assessment that either you run, support, or have experienced yourself. Follow the process in the previous figure:
Identify the key learning outcome(s) being developed:
1. What would be the best and most effective approach for providing feedback to help develop this skill / understanding / competence?
2. At what point would it be best to provide that feedback / guidance / support in the development of the learner?
3. What would be an appropriate and relevant approach to testing the learner’s attainment of the learning outcome?
4. What would be the formative activity which would align best with the previous steps?
The close alignment of the feedback and the summative assessment is fundamental to the feedback being of use to the learner and their ongoing development.
The final section of this module focuses on ensuring that learners benefit from the feedback in their ongoing development.

