AD4 – Engaging students in review of assessments

Students are not only the recipients of an assessment, but they also have a critical role to play in the review process and the quality assurance of an assessment.

Ideally an environment of shared ownership of, and responsibility for assessment needs to be developed. The emphasis of the review process should be in developing shared regulation and deep approaches to learning that require and enable students to get ‘underneath assessment to inform it’ (Evans, 2022).

The review process is an important learning activity. Reviewing the efficacy of an assessment requires the learner to have skills in Critical Evaluation. In particular, the ability to develop a deep understanding of the relationships between learning outcomes, assessment criteria, assessment tasks and course delivery, and one’s role within assessment.

When reviewing, learner’s demonstrate:
· Willingness and ability to engage in critical evaluation of the efficacy of a course and to offer up suggestions for improvement
· Holistic understanding of how course is organised and perspective on how best to support learning for self and others.

To support the process, educators need to:
· Ensure ongoing evaluation integral to curriculum design
· Encourage students to take responsibility by offering solutions and delivering on them
· Partner with students requiring transparency in how assessment is designed and evaluated

Students as a source of data

Engaging learners in feedback about their experiences of assessment should not be complex. For example by ansked questions such as: what did you not understand? What are you most concerned about? What do you think my feedback requires you to focus on?

Focused questions can supply vast amounts of information in a timely way.

Students are a powerful source of data to use in the review and quality assurance processes of an assessment. Data from students to inform these can be gained in a variety of ways.

PRODUCTION ACTIVITY

A (not exhaustive) list of potential data sources for the review of an assessment are listed in this table.

click image to enlarge

Most of these data sources involve the active participation of students.

Ideally any student feedback should be integrated into teaching sessions.

Review processes

 

students in class

Activity: Download the Table in Word format, for each of the data sources, note down some potential benefits and challenges for the process. Reflect on these ideas

This diagram suggests some benefits (in pink) and challenges (in blue) to these data collection methods.

click image to enlarge

Student engagement as partners in revision of assessments

Engaging students in resource development, including design and re-design of assessment, is powerful both for their development and the assessment itself.

Providing students with the empowerment of being partners in the assessment quality assurance process, can enhance their assessment literacy significantly  

DEEP DIVE:

This review of engaging students as partners by Healey et al. (2014) discusses the different approaches to engaging students as partners in higher education. This provides several insights into students as active agents in gaining feedback, devising solutions, and implementing them. 

Feedback on the process to students is important to ensuring continued ‘buy-in’ to their involvement. This table suggests some activities that support students’ active participation in the feedback and revision process.

click image to enlarge

Assessment practices should be regularly evaluated and developed, involving students as much as possible.

Feedback from a range of sources (staff and student feedback; external examiner reports; learning gain measures/ analytics) should be analysed appropriately to ensure the continued effectiveness of the assessment feedback strategy. The next section investigates these data sources in more depth.

Data & learning analytics