AD2 – Aligning a deep approach with assessment

So how can a deep approach be aligned with assessment?

student in libraryThe previous exercise suggests the starting point for that. If we consider the aims of assessment, this informs the approach that needs to be taken:

A key aim of a deep approach is to support:
· Student ownership of the assessment process so that they increasingly take responsibility for their learning and are immersed in understanding for themselves
· Increasing time on task and opportunities for students to get to grips with required content and skill demands.
· Motivation and creativity in the end product being meaningful to the student and having value beyond the immediate assessment point.
· Student engagement in the assessment process also supports students’ lifelong learning skills.

These concepts align very much with the individual taking these ideas forward, using them in the real world, beyond their university course. For more development of these ideas, go to Module AL4 – Clarifying the requirements of the discipline.

There are fundamental metacognitive skills required for this activity:
· Knowership: The learner has a deep understanding of a subject and the strategies necessary to gain deeper insights (Sadler, 2017);
· Creativity: The learner is able to manipulate information and use it in a variety of ways, including novel ways (translation and adaptability skills). (see also the EAT-Erasmus Self-Regulation Report (pp 11-13) on key self-regulation skills).

Both the learner and educator have responsibilities in developing these metacognitive skills:

click image to enlarge

Meaningful assessment

 

This video discusses some of the key concepts underpinning the development of a deep approach, and the role assessment can play in this process and draws on Evans et al., 2015) work on student engagement and high impact pedagogies.

Download the video transcript

PRODUCTION ACTIVITY:

· Can you produce a concept map of how knowledge and skills in a module relate to one another?
· If you repeated this idea with colleagues – what areas of similarity and difference would you identify?
· How could you use an exercise such as this with your students?

REFLECTION ACTIVITY

To what extent would you say your assessments address these three concepts?
· Highlighting the importance of the design/production process of the assessment, as well as the final outcome
· Supporting future professional activity and/or learning of the student
· Underlining the importance of (and practical use of) deep approaches in the discipline

What are the challenges/barriers and affordances/opportunities that hinder or support the alignment of assessments with these concepts? Note some of these down, as we will address them again later.

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT

We have mentioned the term ‘authentic assessment’ several times. While this is not the only form of ‘meaningful’ assessment, it is one of the most highly-addressed within the literature. Authentic assessment is the delivery of assessments that align with real-life activities. Many assessment types in university (most notably time-limited examinations, closed-book assessments, and extended written essays) are quite specific to educational contexts, and activities that the students will probably never have to undertake in their working life.

INVESTIGATION ACTIVITY

Download and read this short position paper by Wiggins (2019), arguing for the importance of authentic assessment.
What elements of this paper most stand out to you as reflecting the concepts of assessment for learning, and assessment as learning?
Are there any elements of this paper that you find problematic?

You might use the EAT Framework Wheel to evaluate the potential benefit from, or lack of, these ideas, against the 12 sub-dimensions of EAT.

Authentic assessment